The "definitive one-volume study of Nuremberg," The Trial of
the Germans is now available in paperback. An astute observer
of the Nuremberg trial, Eugene Davidson has struggled with the
issues it raised: Was it a necessary response to the heinous
crimes of the Third Reich? How were Germany and the Germans
capable of such extraordinary evil? Was the trial just, given the
claims that the defendants were simply serving their country,
doing as they had been told to do? And if not just, was it
nonetheless necessary as a warning to prevent future crimes
against humanity? Davidson's approach to these and other large
questions of justice is made through examination of each of the
defendants in the trial. His reluctant, but firm, conclusion is:
"In a world of mixed human affairs where a rough justice is done
that is better than lynching or being shot out of hand, Nuremberg
may be defended as a political event if not as a court." Some
sentences may have seemed too severe, but none was harsher than
the punishments meted out to innocent people by the regime these
men served. "In a certain sense," says Davidson, "the trial
succeeded in doing what judicial proceedings are supposed to do:
it convinced even the guilty that the verdict against them was
just."
Faulty as the trial was from the legal point of view, a catharsis
of the pent-up emotions of millions of people had to be provided
and a record of what had taken place duly preserved for whatever
use later generations would make of it.
"The [Nuremberg] trial has never been reviewed with the
scholarship, the thoroughness, and the advantages of hindsight
that Eugene Davidson now brings to it in this absorbing and
important book. . . . More than an analysis of the trial . . .
[the biographies] build into a total picture of Nazi Germany. . .
. A major contribution to history and to understanding."—Walter
Millis
"Well researched and compelling."—Boston Globe
"As complete a study as one could hope to have . . . will not be easily
dislodged from its high position of authoritative testimony."—Chicago Tribune
"A masterly, detailed study of the defendants and their prosecutors at
Nuremberg. . . . It raises disturbing questions and provides even more
disturbing answers."—Detroit Free
Press
"A study of the individual defendants and their innocence or guilt . . .
fascinating . . . vastly superior in scholarship and detail."—St. Louis Globe-Democrat
"The presentation is scholarly, well-organized, smoothly written.
The pen portraits, sketched in acid, are sharp and
illuminating."—L. L. Snyder, Saturday Review